What is the difference between a claim and evidence?

Prepare for the New York State Literacy CST Exam with interactive quizzes. Use comprehensive flashcards and multiple-choice questions to enhance your exam readiness. Get the skills you need for success!

Multiple Choice

What is the difference between a claim and evidence?

In argument writing, a claim is the position or statement you’re putting forward. Evidence is the data, details, or examples that back up that claim and help persuade readers. The best choice reflects this relationship: a claim is a statement or position; evidence is data or details that support it. For example, if you claim that a policy improves student outcomes, you would support that claim with evidence like test score improvements, study findings, or concrete examples from schools that implemented the policy. The claim presents what you think is true, and the evidence shows why you think it’s true. Data itself isn’t the claim—it’s what you use to support the claim. An interpretation of events without evidence would be just speculation, not a claim with backing. And an opinion without needing evidence isn’t persuasive; strong arguments rely on evidence to support the claim.

In argument writing, a claim is the position or statement you’re putting forward. Evidence is the data, details, or examples that back up that claim and help persuade readers. The best choice reflects this relationship: a claim is a statement or position; evidence is data or details that support it.

For example, if you claim that a policy improves student outcomes, you would support that claim with evidence like test score improvements, study findings, or concrete examples from schools that implemented the policy. The claim presents what you think is true, and the evidence shows why you think it’s true.

Data itself isn’t the claim—it’s what you use to support the claim. An interpretation of events without evidence would be just speculation, not a claim with backing. And an opinion without needing evidence isn’t persuasive; strong arguments rely on evidence to support the claim.

More practice questions